Dozens of Asian-American parents filtered into a Queens auditorium in January, gathering to protest a local school desegregation plan that they said would drive their children to low-performing schools in far-off neighborhoods. But their anger was really directed at one person: Richard A. Carranza, the leader of New York City’s schools.
They chanted: “Fire Carranza!” and accused the schools chancellor of forcing integration and of discriminating against their children.
The scene — groups of parents venting frustration with Mr. Carranza and his vision for the nation’s largest school system — has been repeated in recent months, from City Hall Park to a dim sum restaurant in Brooklyn.
Those rallies are led by a small yet highly organized group of mostly Asian-American families who travel to the school chancellor’s appearances, wearing T-shirts emblazoned with anti-Carranza messages and holding signs with messages like, “Carranza breeds racism in the name of diversity.”
Mr. Carranza’s focus on racial inequality in city schools has drawn ire from prominent conservatives across the country, many of whom are white. But the Mexican-American chancellor has faced his strongest critics closer to home, from some of those in the city’s Asian community.
That rift, which is at the center of an emotional debate among families of color about merit and fairness in city schools, threatens to undermine the chancellor’s remaining two years as one of the most influential education officials in the country.
“You have this chancellor and this mayor who have all these great ideas, but the ideas don’t include Asians,” said Amy Tse, a Queens mother who frequently attends anti-Carranza rallies.
“They never even mention Asians. It’s always a white-black thing.”
Mr. Carranza’s handling of a 2018 fight over how to enroll more black and Hispanic students in the city’s top public high schoolsoffended and alienated many Asian-Americans — and not just parents.
Sen. John Liu, a Democratic state senator who represents a large Asian population in Queens, helped ensure that the specialized school plan failed in Albany this past summer. “It’s important to be a chancellor for all school kids,” Mr. Liu said. “Two years in, Carranza is falling behind on the curve on that.”
The chancellor has also faced criticism from Representative Grace Meng, a Queens Democrat, along with other Asian-American Democrats in the New York City Council and State Legislature.
And the chasm continues to deepen.
Since the start of this school year, Asian-American parents have accused Mr. Carranza of prejudice over a range of issues, from his decision not to fire an elected parent leader who called Asians “yellow folks” to the fact that the city considered relocating one of the chancellor’s upcoming town hall meetings from Chinatown to Manhattan’s Chelsea neighborhood, before reversing course.
The vitriol and racial division that defined the battle over the so-called specialized high schools have now begun to color a series of seemingly unrelated issues — and stand to influence the school district for years to come.
Shortly after Mr. Carranza arrived in New York in spring 2018, he and Mayor Bill de Blasio announced a plan to get rid of the admissions exam for eight specialized schools, in an effort to boost the number of black and Hispanic students.
Asian students make up a majority of the schools and would lose about half their seats under the city’s proposal. Asian-American parents and politicians were not consulted about the plan before it was announced.